I know that we are going to be discussing various social bookmarking tools as a group (next time we meet), but I thought I would explore a few on my own seeing I know so little about this technology. I looked at
delicious and
diigo in depth, and
connotea as a comparison to delicious when I was deciding what I should join when I get home.
DiigoYou can create a Diigo account for free, either adding in your details from scratch or using your Facebook profile to create an account. No software apart from an internet browser is needed. The creators claim diigo enables you to ‘highlight and search the web’. It is a research tool and a ‘knowledge sharing community’. You can highlight part of pages on the internet, and make a comment (great for reading online) which will remain on the page. You can bookmark the page for later, add tags. You can also organise, share and display your bookmarks. You can book you’re and other people’s annotations in the side bar, as well as view your saved bookmarks (search by keywords). Diigo claims to set itself apart from other social bookmarking services because it has a facebook type feature to help you stay in touch with friends or others that share your same interests and see what they are tagging. Diigo groups means that colleagues can collaborate and share their findings (group bookmarks, sticky notes, forum discussions). You can also send message or bookmarks to your contacts. Other community tools include participating in larger networks that form around a particular site or tag (e.g. the New York Times). Diigo can display recommended bookmarks that align with your interests from other users. I found this information on this YouTube video.The tools on diigo are used mainly to tag free websites. The Web 2.0 tutorial stated that ‘There are several other tools which are intended more for scholarly resources on the web and on proprietary databases. The best known of these are probably CiteULike and Connotea’. So this is probably more of a social interest and bookmarking website, rather than scholarly or academic, many of our lecturers and tutors seem to use delicious or connotea for more simple social bookmarking (without the facebook like networking options). All your bookmarks are stored in the Diigo account that you create, and so it is accessible from any computer with Internet access (any browser).
What similarities / differences can you see with bookmarking/ favourites?Similarities: your bookmarks are stored and can be accessed from your own computer. The bookmarks can be organised according to their subject through tagging, although tagging offers more flexibility in terms of searching and retrieving bookmarks (you can search your bookmarks by keyword rather than remembering which folder you saved into on your favourites).
Differences: Diigo is a social networking and bookmarking site, with the facility to join networks and stay up to date with your friends and contacts’ latest internet finds. The idea that colleagues could co-ordinate their research on a topic and create a group forum is interesting, but I am not sure whether LinkedIn would serve that purpose better. It is just different. The professional use of Diigo would be resource-centred and that might be better for a group project.
DeliciousDelicious allows users to make bookmarks more portable and useful by accessing them from browser rather than just one computer. The creators of delicious describe it as
“All your stuff in one place. Get to your bookmarks from any computer, anytime, anywhere.”To get started you need to enter your details and sign up for your free account, then you need to add the delicious buttons/icons to your browser so you can add bookmarks to your account easily. You can install add-ons for whatever browser you are using (this is optional). You can import existing bookmarks too. Then will come making your account more personalised and join/create a network.
- Tagging a site that you have decided to save as a bookmark can help the user find it more easily later, and creates a personalised site-organisation system to avoid a chaotic list of sites from all subjects. You search through your saved bookmarks using key words (tags).
- It is a type of social bookmarking because your bookmarks are public, and your colleagues or friends can view your bookmarks (you can also view theirs). You can add them as friends and browse through their bookmarks. This establishes a network which can broaden the range of resources available to all of you on common topics.
- Delicious supports Internet Explorer 5 or 6, Firefox, and Safari; but you still save bookmarks on a browser that delicious does not support like AOL or MSN by using the ‘Save a new bookmark" link in the top right corner of most pages, or visiting
delicious.com/save directly. The FAQ page advises that ‘You may want to add that page to your browser's bookmarks/favorites for easy access’. (Information from
http://delicious.com/help/faq#tools)
What similarities / differences can you see with bookmarking/ favourites?
Similarities: You still save bookmarks so you can return to the site later. In the favourites section of your browser you can still organise the bookmarks in folders and sub-folders.
Differences: You can access the delicious bookmarks from any computer, not just your own PC or MAC. The system of tagging means you can search for bookmarks (and find them) under a number of different key word categories, and not simply in one folder. The traditional favourites bookmarks on your computer cannot be shared or viewed by other people unless they use your computer.
Delicious includes the social features of creating a ‘network’ which connects you to other users of delicious, and this feature collects your favourite users bookmarks in one place. Delicious has an Inbox link that you to send and receive bookmarks directly to/from other users who are part of your network (or to anyone else in delicious). Delicious states that “Delicious can be easier and quicker than email or instant messaging, and your friend or coworker will have a permanent copy of the link that's easy to add to their own bookmarks.” (
http://delicious.com/help/faq#socialbookmarking)
Trying to decide between delicious and connotea…After having explored the merits of both delicious and diigo, I am seeking to join a simple bookmarking site without all of the additional tools offered by diigo (at this time). I looked at connotea as another possible alternative. It seems to be more professional as it is marketed at a demographic who wants to share references with ‘colleagues’. They claim that it is easy to save and organise references with one click, and access these references from any computer. You can click on related tags to explore other users’ libraries. The references you post can be public, private or shared with a group. There is no storage limit, and it has the ability to save bibliographic information from sites (especially journal sites) which allow it. Even if you cannot do this, you can bookmark and save any page you find on the web. I really like the sound of this! It seems to be suited to students for academic research purposes.
I look foward to talking about the different social bookmarking sites that you either use or are thinking of joining. Particularly, what they are like compared to endnote, also how to integrate the features with that software. I haven't been able to download it at home because of the dial up connection, it keeps timing out.